In Indian Families, property is often demarcated as a symbol of pride, honour and heritage. Out of love and affection, the parent or the donor transfers their property in the form of a gift to their children, loved ones, and associates. The donor usually believes that this action will lead him to be loved and cared for, but life is not what we usually expect. When these expectations of the donors are not fulfilled, they find themselves in a vulnerable situation, stripped of both dignity and assets. In that situation, a question arises as to whether the donor can reclaim the property by revoking the gift deed?
This post will examine the law governing gift deeds, what they are, and in which situations the gift could eventually be revoked. The post would also guide the donors about the special powers of the conditional clauses and how they can be added to the deed for the protection of their interests when violated.
As per the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, under Section 122, a gift means the voluntary transfer of property by one person to another without any monetary consideration. The person who makes a gift of property is termed a donor, and the person to whom a gift is made is referred to as a donee.
To ensure its legality before the court of law, a gift deed needs to be made out of the voluntary intention of the donor, acceptance by the donee during the lifetime of the donor while being mentally fit to take such a decision and registration of the deed, if relating to any property, under the Registration Act, 1908.
Under Indian Law, it is a general rule that once a gift deed is signed, accepted and registered, the transfer of ownership of the property is absolute and final, making the recipient the sole owner, and the gift can only be taken if very specific legal exceptions are met.
In the case of Renikuntla Rajamma (Dead) by Legal Representatives v. K. Sarwanamma, the Supreme Court held that once a gift deed is voluntarily accepted, executed and registered, it immediately transfers the ownership to the donee and the gift remains valid unless it falls within the statutory grounds for revocation.
Section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, allows the donor to cancel the gift deed if certain legal conditions are met, such as mutual consent, failure of performance of a specified condition written in the gift deed, or if his consent was taken through unlawful means like fraud, coercion or undue influence. Also, a donor cannot unilaterally revoke a registered gift deed solely because he changed his mind.
The most remarkable aspect of Section 126 is the addition of the specified conditions in the gift deed. An explicit clause in the gift deed has the power to revoke the existing deed if the specified conditions aren’t fulfilled.
In J. Radha Krishna v. Pagadala Bharathi, the Supreme Court refused to uphold the cancellation of the gift deed, holding that Section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act permits revocation only where the donor and donee had agreed to a valid condition of revocation at the time of the gift. In the absence of such a reservation in the deed and with no proof of a mutual agreement rendering the donation revocable because of failure to support the donor, the annulment of the donation was declared to be ineffective.
The intention of Section 23 of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2023, is to protect the interests and dignity of senior citizens after the execution of a gift deed. This means that if a senior citizen gifts a piece of property on the condition that they will be taken care of and the right amenities will be provided, and if this condition is not followed by the person receiving the gift, the law may declare that the gift deed was created as a result of coercion or fraud.
There is a debate regarding whether there should be an explicit maintenance clause should be added to the deed. As these deeds are mostly made out by the senior citizen in love and affection, it must be implied that it is the duty of the donor to maintain the elderly person.
While the Supreme Court in Sudesh Chhikara v. Ramti Devi ruled that transfer must be expressly conditioned on the transferee’s obligation to maintain the senior citizen, the Karnataka High Court in Sri Venkataiah v. State of Karnataka adopted a more purposive approach. The Court held that the obligation to maintain may, in appropriate cases, be inferred from the surrounding circumstances and the familial relationship, even in the absence of an express maintenance clause. This decision reflects a judicial attempt to prevent the formalisation of the senior citizens to protect their dignity in the non-performance of the obligations by the donee.
A donor can protect their interests by adding certain conditional clauses in the gift deed before its registration, agreed upon by the donee, and officially registered with the local Sub-Registrar’s Office as per the Registration Act, 1908. These clauses prevent the deed from becoming an irreversible trap and serve as an escape mechanism for the donor when things don’t go his way.
Firstly, mention a clear Maintenance Clause: According to it, the transfer will be contingent on the donee’s supply of food, proper care, and medical treatment to the donor; failure to which, the deed could be revocable and asset ownership will go back to the name of the donor.
Secondly, the donor can add a Life Interest Clause, which specifies that while the transfer of ownership has been done to the donee’s name, the donor will take a life interest to live in and enjoy the property. This will prevent the unnecessary eviction of the donor or the property from being sold without the donor’s consent. The Supreme Court validates this clause when real estate is the subject matter of the gift deed.
While these clauses aim to prevent the donor from unfair treatment, the donor must be aware that the conditions mentioned in the clause must be lawful and reasonable. If any of the terms of the clause is deemed unlawful, it can be declared void by the competent authority. So, the donor must avoid drafting any immoral condition in the deed.
When you are about to gift your property to your next generation, remember that this is one of the most heartfelt acts of love & trust from the parents for their children. But don’t let them take advantage of their position because they will expose the vulnerable donor.
In such situations, Indian Law has been a lifesaver for many through section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act And Also section 23 of the Senior Citizens’ Act, which allows the owner to reclaim his gifted property if some conditions are met. So, do make sure that before donating your precious properties, you have some sort of conditional documentations/Statutory Protection with you to claim back what was given away.
Written by Tushar Soni
Legal Intern, Sandhu Law Offices